BankDirect VS Commerce Bank

Which bank is better for you?

  • Financial Rates: 4.0 Star Icon
  • Customer Service: 3.0 Star Icon
  • Website Experience: 5.0 Star Icon
  • Bank Fees: 4.0 Star Icon
No Rate Information
Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon

Pros:

  • Low required opening amounts
  • Reimbursement of ATM fees
  • Variety of personal deposit accounts
  • Money market account earns good rates

Cons:

  • Highest MMA rate requires large amount
  • High required amount to open CDs
  • Checking accounts have a monthly fee
  • Must mail in application to open account
  • Financial Rates: 3.0 Star Icon
  • Customer Service: 5.0 Star Icon
  • Website Experience: 5.0 Star Icon
  • Bank Fees: 3.0 Star Icon
No Rate Information
Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon Star Icon

Pros:

  • Rewards for saving in money market
  • ID restoration
  • Many accounts, even business accounts
  • mySpending card

Cons:

  • Only three withdrawals per month
  • Low-interest rates
  • Accounts have lots of fees
  • Customer service not open 24/7
BankDirect Review

Most of the BankDirect accounts have a low amount required to open the account. BankDirect checking accounts only require $500 to open. Both BankDirect money market accounts require $500 to open. The basic savings account only requires $100 to open.

BankDirect does not own any ATMs; they reimburse their customers the ATM fees. The first four ATM withdrawals per statement cycle are refunded. The refunds are up to $2.50 per transaction. There is a withdrawal limit of $500 from an ATM each day.

BankDirect offers a variety of personal deposit accounts. There are three different checking accounts and two different money market accounts. There are a variety of different CD terms available. BankDirect offers one savings account. There are no business accounts available.

The BankDirect Money Market Plus account offers a competitive interest rate. BankDirect also offers a mileage money market account. This account earns American Airline miles. Both MMA require $500 to open. The mileage money market account earns much lower interest rates. You earn miles instead of interest. There is no monthly fee for either account.

To earn the high rates offered on the BankDirect Money Market Plus account you must have $10,000 in the account. Amounts under $10,000 do not earn any interest. Only $500 is required to open this account, but to earn any interest requires $10,000.

BankDirect offers a variety of different CD terms. The required amount to open any of the CDs is $10,000. There is no monthly fee. The interest rates for CDs are competitive. The 12-month, 18-months, 24-months and 36-month CDs offer the most competitive rates. To open a mileage CD also requires $10,000.

Two of the BankDirect checking accounts have monthly fees. The interest and mileage checking accounts both have a monthly fee. The fee is waived for the interest checking account if you have at least $2,500 in the account. The mileage checking does not list a way to waive that monthly fee.

Opening an account with BankDirect is not entirely online. To open an account, you must fill out the application online, then print off part and mail it in. You will then receive a welcome kit within one to two weeks. Once you get your kit, you can finish setting up your account.

Read the full BankDirect review.

Commerce Bank Review

Get rewarded for saving money with Commerce Bank. When you open a myRewards money market account, you will earn a bonus at the end of each year. Commerce pays 0.05% of the average collected month-end balance after every 12 months. The maximum reward each year is $200.

ID restoration protects your information. Family ID restoration protects you and your family. Know if someone uses your personal information without your knowledge. ID Restoration Plus offers proactive credit and internet monitoring. Protect you and one family member by signing up for the plus plan. There is a monthly service charge of $2.95 for the family plan and $8.95 for the plus plan.

Commerce Bank offers a variety of accounts. Checking accounts, account for students, savings, money market, and CDs. They also offer business checking and savings accounts, loans, bonds, investments, and credit cards.

Commerce offers a mySpending card. This is a reloadable Visa debit card. Load the amount you want onto the card. The card is accepted anywhere Visa is. There is no monthly fee. It costs $5.95 to buy the card the first time. You must load it with at least $20 the first time. There is a loading limit of $3,000 per week.

Savings accounts only allow for three withdrawals per billing cycle. Any more than three will cost you $2.00 per withdrawal. Federal regulations allow six withdrawals from a savings account per billing cycle.

Interest rates for Commerce Bank accounts are not competitive with other online-only banks. Their rates are typical of brick and mortar banks.

Accounts with Commerce Bank have a plethora of fees. Accounts have monthly service charges. There are also fees for paper statements, some E-statements, and non-Commerce Bank ATM fees. The student checking account has a $2 fee for every check written and for each teller-assisted withdrawal. Know the requirements to have fees waived.

Customer service is not open 24/7. Customer service hours are Monday-Friday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Saturday from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. These times are Central Time. There is a 24-hour account information line.

Read the full Commerce Bank review.

Favorite Rates

CIT Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.25%
Rate 2.23%
For APY $100
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
$25k+ balance or $100+/month deposit for 2.25% APY. Member FDIC.
Learn More &
Open Account
Citizens Access
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.25%
Rate 2.23%
For APY $5,000
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
$5,000 minimum balance to obtain APY. Absolutely no fees.
Learn More &
Open Account
Sallie Mae
MMA 12/10/2018
APY 2.20%
Rate 2.18%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook Yes
Member FDIC Insured.
Learn More &
Open Account
TIAA Bank
MMA 12/10/2018
APY 2.15%
Intro Rate 2.13%
Intro Duration 12 Months
Post Intro 1.09%
For APY $5,000
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook Yes
Earn a top 5% yield- always! Open an Account today. FDIC insured.
Learn More &
Open Account
Live Oak Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.10%
Rate 2.08%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
Member FDIC. Earn 23x the National Average
Learn More &
Open Account
State Farm Bank
MMA 12/10/2018
APY 2.10%
Intro Rate 2.08%
Intro Duration 12 Months
Post Intro 1.00%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $10.00
Checkbook Yes
Intro APY, $1,000 to Open, $5,000 Min Bal post intro, See Limits
Learn More &
Open Account
Synchrony Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.05%
Rate 2.03%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
Great Rates + Safety = Peace of Mind
Learn More &
Open Account
Barclays
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.05%
Rate 2.03%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
No Minimum Balance. No Monthly Maintenance Fees. FDIC Insured.
Learn More &
Open Account
Capital One 360
MMA 12/10/2018
APY 2.00%
Rate 1.98%
For APY $10,000
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook Yes
One of the Nation's Top Savings Rates - No Fees
Learn More &
Open Account
American Express National Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.00%
Rate 1.98%
For APY $1
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
Accounts offered by American Express National Bank. Member FDIC
Learn More &
Open Account
Discover Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 2.00%
Rate 1.98%
For APY $0
Monthly Fee $0.00
Checkbook No
Member FDIC Insured.
Learn More &
Open Account
E*TRADE Bank
Savings 12/10/2018
APY 1.90%
Rate 1.88%
For APY $1
Monthly Fee $10.00
Checkbook No
Make the most of your savings - higher rates & a whole lot more!
Learn More &
Open Account